If you listened to our podcast from Saturday, and you really should have, your ears would have been witness to what one could call “a lively discussion” in polite society. But who are we kidding? Israelisms podcast isn’t about polite society!
Charley maintained that our domestic policy, in particular with regards to the religious parties such as Shas are a danger to our existence as a nation. In his eyes it is more so than the ever present threat from our neighbors. I think that both these threats are real but they fall under the comparison of apples and oranges. The only thing that joins them is that obviously they are threats against Israel as we know it and we don’t want either of them to come to fruition.
Charley could not understand how the average Israeli, aka Yosef the plumber, doesn’t demand action on this threat posed by the ultra orthodox, who don’t fully participate in Israeli society but take from it in ever bigger bites until there will be nothing left. In addition the ultra orthodox do not see democracy as necessary in a Jewish state. Without democracy, individual freedoms are not protected. From both an economical and a social perspective we will be in trouble.
I don’t disagree with Charley that the threat is real. I do however understand the psyche of the Israeli citizen. It’s actually the reaction that any people anywhere in the world would have. What do you worry about more? The missile that is already aimed at your home or the coming economic crunch that will come but isn’t here now? Look at America post 9/11. What scared them more, Al Qaeda or a looming economic crisis? You guessed it and so the “war on terror” was born.
Israeli’s have been dealing with a threat to their lives for more than the 62 years that the State of Israel exists. The threat will not even end when and if there is a formation of a Palestinian state. The extremists of Hamas and Hezbollah, Iran and Syria will see to it. So don’t blame the public if they worry more about their very ability to stay alive.
Blame the leadership instead. Charley said the politicians use the threat against Israel for their own good, they inflate it so they don’t have to do anything about our internal problems. While I agree that PM Netanyahu is only interested in staying in power I think it trivializes the very real threat posed by our neighbors to claim it is inflated. I think our leaders can and should be dealing with both the external and internal issues. It can be done. United States President Lincoln comes to mind as an example of a leader who dealt with war and issues affecting the every day lives of the citizens. Sadly this is not the case with the present government. We need better leaders and we should demand it. However Joe Public will still fear more the clear and present danger over a threat that is down the line where hopefully there will be time left to fix it. It is what it is. That’s why leadership is so important.